Skip to content

Comparison

Magnolia City vs Black Orchid

Side-by-side comparison of Magnolia City by D.S. & Durga and Black Orchid by Tom Ford.

 Magnolia CityBlack Orchid
BrandD.S. & DurgaTom Ford
Concentration--
Rating--
Reviews--
Longevity--
Sillage--
Value--
Price-$250
Top NotesGalbanum, Lemon, Moss floxBergamot, Gardenia (listed in some retailer notes) [2], Mandarin Orange, Mandarin / citrus accents (listed by some retailers) [2], Black Currant, Black truffle (truffle) [4], Black currant (pers. listings include) [2], Bitter orange / Amalfi lemon (citrus) [2][4], Bergamot [4], Truffle, Amalfi Lemon
Heart NotesOrchid, Narcissus, Magnolia brooklynensisFruity Notes, Orchid, Gardenia, Ylang-Ylang, Rum / rum absolute (golden rum accord) [4][1], Jasmine, Ylang-ylang [4][2], Lotus, Jasmine (reported in some vendor notes) [2], Spices / lotus wood (vendors list spices/lotus accord) [2][5], Black orchid (orchid accord) [4][2], Spices
Base NotesCherry Tree, White Musk, Saucer MagnoliaSandalwood, Patchouli [4][1], Vanilla (creamy vanilla / gourmand facets) [4][2], Vetiver [2], White Musk, Incense, Vanille, Incense [2], White musk / amber / Mexican chocolate (reported by retailers) [2], Sandalwood (reported by some sources) [2], Vetiver, Mexican chocolate, Amber, Patchouli
AccordsFloral, Citrus, Green, Aromatic, LactonicWarm Spicy, Woody, Gourmand, Earthy, Sweet, Amber, Balsamic, Powdery

Not sure which to choose?

Get a personalized AI recommendation based on your taste profile.

Discover ScentGraph